mathstodon.xyz is one of the many independent Mastodon servers you can use to participate in the fediverse.
A Mastodon instance for maths people. We have LaTeX rendering in the web interface!

Server stats:

2.8K
active users

#latexmath

0 posts0 participants0 posts today
Replied to Terence Tao

@tao Although GPT-based content could be very useful, I think the main issue is verifying the authenticity of the proof. I do like your idea of a #GPT including a Lean proof but as you posted not too long ago, the difficulty is making sure that the Lean version is actually proving what is written. I could imagine giving a GPT the #LaTeXmath with the Lean proof and asking it to check if there are any discrepancies, but in my experience neither GPTs nor humans are good at spotting subtle errors.

recently reprinted an interview I had a few months ago on the future of proof assistants and in : scientificamerican.com/article . In it, I made the following assertion:

"I think in the future, instead of typing up our proofs, we would explain them to some . And the GPT will try to formalize it in as you go along. If everything checks out, the GPT will [essentially] say, “Here’s your paper in ; here’s your Lean proof. If you like, I can press this button and submit it to a journal for you.” It could be a wonderful assistant in the future."

This statement seems to have received a mixed reception, in particular it has been interpreted as an assertion that mathematicians would be become lazier and sloppier with writing proofs. I think the best way to illustrate what I mean by this assertion is by a worked example, which is already within the capability of current technology. At terrytao.wordpress.com/2016/10 I have a moderately tricky problem in complex analysis. In chatgpt.com/share/63c5774a-d58 , I explained this problem and its solution to in an interactive fashion, and after the proof was explained, GPT was able to provide a LaTeX file of the solution, which one can find at terrytao.wordpress.com/wp-cont . GPT performed quite well in my opinion, fleshing out my sketched argument into quite a coherent and reasonably rigorous full proof. This is not 100% of what I envisioned in the article - in particular the rigorous Lean translation in order to guarantee correctness is missing, which I think is an essential requirement before this workflow can be used for research quality publications - but hopefully will illustrate what I had in mind with the quote.

Green, blue and purple dismantled cubes reassembled floating on dark blue background.
Scientific American · AI Will Become Mathematicians’ ‘Co-Pilot’By Christoph Drösser

I want to be #movingservers, I'm looking for a fairly well moderated and rarely blocked server. My current server is blocked by too many instances for various reasons. It would be nice if it supported #latexmath rendering, was STEM or technology oriented and had a decent chance of being around in 10 years. Any ideas?