Jordi is a user on You can follow them or interact with them if you have an account anywhere in the fediverse. If you don't, you can sign up here.
Jordi @JordiGH

I've wondered why does an otherwise unremarkable movie have the most realistic depiction of an algebraic . Seriously, it's so realistic that I've referred to it a couple of times to remind myself how this proof goes. Why does this dinky little movie have the most realistic fictional mathematician ever?

· Web · 4 · 5

Look at her, that actress, perfectly explaining that diagram chase. Draws the right arrows too. Points at all the right parts of the diagrams. Pronounces everything correctly. Correctly dismisses the snotty student's objections. And the other actor even calls it a diagram chase.

Was the screenwriter a grad school dropout or something?

Huh, the Salamander lemma:

"If you don’t like diagram chases, it’s likely that you still won’t like them once you know the Salamander lemma. The salamanders chase the diagrams for you, but you still have to chase the salamanders. I think the salamander proofs are easier to explain (once you know the Salamander lemma), and it’s easier to see where you use the hypotheses. "

The titular salamander of the lemma, front and centre. They even drew little feet on it.

@kimreece Oh yeah, you like algebra? Or salamanders?

Both! And such luck for me, as I have just needed it.

"I'm impressed -- her gestures are pretty much what I'd expect from someone actually teaching this proof. Did they use a math double for this scene?"

I love this YouTube comment. I want to be a math stunt double in the movies too.

@JordiGH I did a bit of googling and stumbled upon a Rolling Stone article from 1980:

There's a couple of lovely paragraphs about Jill Clayburgh's preparation for the teacher's role (and the student actually studied maths!), but the article doesn't explain where the screenwriter's admiration for mathematics comes from.

@miramarco "'Oh, no. This is all wrong.' She erased it and put it up herself. She did the scene several times, wonderfully"

Wow, badass.

@JordiGH May have stood in on a lecture as prep, or had an adviser on set? Not uncommon aiui.

@ersatzmaus Yeah, but they have those on The Big Bang theory too and the actors are not this convincing.

@JordiGH Maybe they did it better on the movie :) Also the BBT characters are mostly grotesques which probably doesn't help.